Call For A Free Consultation (855) 534-1490
Call For A Free Consultation (855) 534-1490
Call For A Free Consultation (855) 534-1490
In a trio of cases since 2010, the US Supreme Court has telegraphed “best practices” for avoiding class arbitrations for consumer and employee claims.
First the “best practices.” If you are a businesses that wants to arbitrate disputes but wants to prevent class wide arbitration pay attention. The US Supreme Court appears to be telling you to:
This should prevent a party to the arbitration agreement (i.e. a consumer or employee) from suing your business on a class wide basis not only in court but also in arbitration. The consumer or employee may sue you in arbitration but only as an individual. This limits your exposure to the individual dispute at hand which is the point of arbitration from a business defendant’s view point. Think consumer or employee lawsuits – what business wants to be in front of a jury on such claims at all, let alone if a “class action” is involved?
The trio of United States Supreme Court cases since 2010:
The first case Stolt-Nielsen S.A. basically said where there is “no agreement” to arbitrate on a class-wide basis there can be no class wide arbitration. The result: arbitration panel could not force a party to arbitrate on a class wide basis as that exceeded the panel’s powers.
The second case AT&T Mobility basically said if the parties agree to an express waiver of class-wide arbitration in a consumer arbitration agreement, no state law rule can trump the parties’ agreement. The result: consumer (Concepcion) could sue AT&T Mobility for its alleged consumer fraud, but had to do so in private binding arbitration and on an individual basis only, not on a class-wide basis because Concepcion agreed to it. Sure, said the US Supreme Court, the business can strong arm the consumer and force them to sign such an agreement (an “adhesion contract”), but that’s not a sufficient reason to refuse enforcement of the arbitration agreement in accordance with the parties’ no class arbitration terms.
The third case Oxford Health Plans basically said that if the arbitration agreement could be read to allow class arbitration and the parties allow the arbitrator to interpret the language they have to live with the arbitrator’s decision. Arbitration decisions will be overturned only in “unusual circumstances.” That’s not one of them. Even if the arbitrator made a serious error in interpreting the language, the interpretation must stand when the parties “bargained for the arbitrator’s construction [interpretation] of their agreement.”
For agreements to arbitrate under the FAA, we are reminded of the following general rules: